We were a July fire
Sunburn, slow kiss, all-nighter
Stuck between forever and my fall
Yeah, we were a walkin' definition
Of gettin' ahead of where we were headin'
We wonder why we hit a wall

I play it over and over again
All of our coulda and couldn'ta beens
I'm second guessin'
Girl I got questions

What did we have?
Did we give this up too fast?
Baby, were we meant to be a burnt out match?
Would we have lasted a little while longer?
And I need to know
Were we right to let this go?
Maybe it's me that's missin' that closure
'Cause it's over
Girl I gotta ask
What did we have?

If it's just me, I'll move on
Let the overthinkin' get gone
But I've been thinkin' girl that maybe
Just maybe
This is somethin' that we shouldn't close the door on yet
Maybe there's a reason that I can't forget
Tell me now baby if it's all in my head

What did we have?
Did we give this up too fast?
Baby, were we meant to be a burnt out match?
Would we have lasted a little while longer?
And I need to know
Were we right to let this go?
Maybe it's me that's missin' that closure
'Cause it's over
Girl I gotta ask
What did we have?
(What did we, what did we) What did we have?
(What did we, what did we) What did we have?
(What did we, what did we) What did we have?

I play it over and over again
All of our coulda and couldn'ta beens
I'm second guessin'
Girl I got questions

What did we have?
Did we give this up too fast?
Baby, were we meant to be a burnt out match?
Would we have lasted a little while longer?
And I need to know
Were we right to let this go?
Maybe it's me that's missin' that closure
'Cause it's over
Girl I gotta ask
What did we have?
(What did we, what did we) What did we have?
(What did we, what did we) What did we have?
(What did we, what did we) What did we have?